Ice Cream Sundae Bar

Who said dessert can’t be an experience? Transform your next gathering with an Ice Cream Sundae Bar! I’m sharing my how-to guide along with all my best tips, theme ideas, and so much more. From classic toppings to unique twists, I’ve got the scoop on setting up the perfect ice cream sundae bar. 

An ice cream sundae bar becomes an instant centerpiece and conversation starter. Friends and family will love sharing sundae-building strategies, discussing their favorite combinations, and perhaps even sparking a little friendly competition over who can craft the most decadent creation.

When it comes to simple joys, few things can beat the pleasure of a well-crafted ice cream sundae. But imagine taking that joy and magnifying it by sharing it with friends and family, all while letting them craft their perfect dessert. That’s the beauty of an ice cream sundae bar. It’s more than just a dessert station; it’s a place for creativity, conversations, and connections. 

You’re Go-To Guide

Drawing from my own experience, I’ll share a straightforward guide on how to set up your own sundae bar and provide tips to make the process smooth and delightful for everyone involved. Whether it’s a summer backyard bash, a child’s birthday party, an elegant indoor soirée, or even a cozy movie night with loved ones, the ice cream sundae bar concept can be adapted and themed accordingly.

An ice cream sundae bar doesn’t have to be extravagant or expensive. The magic lies in the shared experience, the laughter over quirky sundae combinations, and the simple act of coming together over something sweet. As you can I see, I styled my ice cream sundae bar in my living room bookcase. I used a bunch of glass storage jars for all of my cones, toppings, and sauces. A few decorative touches, including a colorful fabric pendant garland, brought it all together! 

So, if you’re looking for a dessert idea that combines fun, flexibility, and flavor, this Ice Cream Sundae Bar is the perfect treat. Dive into this sweet endeavor, and you’ll soon discover why it’s a hit with everyone who tries it!

Why You’ll Love This Idea

• One of the most significant advantages of an ice cream sundae bar is the personalization it offers. Every guest can create their dream dessert by tailoring it to their unique tastes so each spoonful will be a pure delight.  
• More than just eating, constructing the perfect sundae becomes a fun activity for all ages. Whether it’s kids discovering their favorite toppings or adults reminiscing about their childhood ice cream memories, the process is sure to generate smiles and laughter.
• While the initial setup requires some effort, once it’s up and running guests can serve themselves. This allows hosts to relax, mingle, and enjoy the party without constantly attending to dessert duties.

Ingredients

The best part about an ice cream sundae bar is that you can put together any combination of ice creams and condiments to create an epic treat station. Feel free to mix it up like I did or base it around a theme. Perhaps you could do all things chocolate or design it around a specific holiday. The choice is yours. Following are a few ingredient ideas to get you started.

Ice Cream Base:

• vanilla ice cream
• chocolate ice cream
• strawberry ice cream
• two ingredient no-churn ice cream

Optional: Consider if you’ll need a non-dairy/vegan ice cream alternative. You can also include other favorite flavors (mint chocolate chip, cookie dough, etc.) if desired. 

Toppings:

Chocolatey Delights:

• chocolate chips (milk, dark, white, or peanut butter chips, etc.) 
• hot fudge sauce
• chocolate sprinkles 
• homemade Nutella magic shell

Nutty Complements:

• peanuts
• almonds 
• walnuts 

Sweet Surprises:

• mini marshmallows
• candy pieces like M&Ms or Reese’s Pieces
• gummy bears or Sour Patch candies

Fruity Accents:

• sliced fresh strawberries
• sliced fresh bananas
• maraschino cherries 

Classic Toppings:

• homemade whipped cream 
• rainbow sprinkles
• caramel sauce

Gourmet Touches:

• shredded coconut
• crushed cookies or brownies
• fruit syrups (such as blueberry or raspberry)

Cones & Carriers:

• traditional ice cream cones 
• waffle cones 
• dessert bowls (glass, ceramic, or edible) 

How To Make

Once you’ve gathered all of your Ice Cream Sundae Bar ingredients, you’re ready to put it all together. I’ll walk you through the easy steps below. I’ve also provided a full ingredient list and detailed instructions in the printable recipe card at the end of this post.

1. Setup: Choose a location for your sundae bar, whether it’s on a shelf, counter, or table. Ensure it’s easily accessible.
2. Ice Cream Placement: Place the ice creams either in chilled bowls with scoops or keep them in their original containers with lids removed for easy access.
3. Toppings Organization: In separate bowls or containers, organize your toppings by type. Use tongs for some, and spoons for others, depending on the consistency and size of the topping.
4. Cones & Bowls Display: Set up a station with stacked cones and neatly arranged bowls.
5. Serve & Enjoy: Allow guests to create their personalized sundaes by layering their favorite ice creams with delectable toppings.
6. Storage: After the party, store any leftover toppings in airtight containers and refrigerate or freeze leftover ice cream immediately.

Theme Ideas

Pretty simple, right? As I mentioned above, you can keep it classic like I did or follow a theme. Themed ice cream sundae bars can make any gathering extra special. Here’s a list of theme ideas and accompanying ingredients:

Chocolate Lover’s Dream

• Ice Creams: chocolate, dark chocolate, chocolate mint, and white chocolate
• Toppings: hot fudge, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate chips, brownie bits, and chocolate cookie crumbles

Summer Solstice Soiree

• Ice Creams: lemon sorbet, peach, mango, and raspberry
• Toppings: fresh summer fruits (such as strawberries, blueberries, and kiwi slices), citrus zest, and mint leaves

Halloween Haunt

• Ice Creams: pumpkin spice, orange sherbet, and black licorice (If you dare!)
• Toppings: candy corn, gummy worms, orange and black sprinkles, and crushed chocolate cookies (for “dirt”)

Christmas Winter Wonderland

• Ice Creams: peppermint, gingerbread, and eggnog
• Toppings:  crushed candy canes, gingerbread cookie crumbles, green & red sprinkles, and a dollop of whipped cream with a cherry on top for a “Santa hat”

Birthday Blast

• Ice Creams: Funfetti or birthday cake, strawberry, and cookie dough
• Toppings: rainbow sprinkles, maraschino cherries, whipped cream, and assorted colorful candies

Tropical Paradise

• Ice Creams: coconut, pineapple, passion fruit, and mango
• Toppings: shredded coconut, fresh pineapple chunks, kiwi slices, and a drizzle of passion fruit syrup

Vintage Diner Delights

• Ice Creams: classic vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate
• Toppings: hot fudge, caramel sauce, banana slices, whipped cream, and maraschino cherries

Coffee Shop Chill

• Ice Creams: coffee, caramel macchiato, and mocha
• Toppings: crushed espresso beans, caramel drizzle, chocolate-covered coffee beans, and whipped cream

Berry Bonanza

• Ice Creams: strawberry, raspberry ripple, blueberry, and blackberry
• Toppings: fresh berries, berry compotes, berry-flavored syrups, and whipped cream

Around the World Adventure

• Ice Creams: green tea (Asia), dulce de leche (Latin America), pistachio (Mediterranean), and chai (India)
• Toppings: mochi bits, caramel drizzle, crushed pistachios, and cinnamon

Frequently Asked Questions

How much ice cream should I buy for my guests?

On average, you can estimate about two to three scoops per person. For a gathering of 20 people, a gallon to a gallon and a half should suffice, but it’s always a good idea to have a little extra. 

Can I set up an ice cream sundae bar outdoors during a summer event?

Absolutely! However, make sure to keep the ice cream in a cooler or ice-filled tub to prevent melting. Have a shaded area or umbrella over the sundae bar to keep the toppings cool.

How can I cater to guests with dietary restrictions?

Offer alternatives like non-dairy/vegan ice creams and gluten-free cones. Be sure to label these clearly and keep them slightly separate to avoid cross-contamination.

What drinks pair well with an ice cream sundae bar?

Cold milk, iced coffee, and soft drinks are popular choices. If you want to get fancy, root beer for root beer floats and/or cold brew for affogatos are delightful additions.

How can I keep my ice cream firm throughout the event?

You’ll want to bring the ice cream out just before you’re ready to serve. If indoors, consider turning down the thermostat a bit. For outdoor settings, keep the tubs of ice cream in larger bowls filled with ice. Rotate them out with backups from the freezer as needed.

More Dessert Ideas You May Enjoy

• Wedding Cookie Table Ideas and Recipes
• Desserts In a Jar Ideas
• The Best Ice Cream Desserts
• Delicious Lemon Dessert Recipes
• Unique and Fun Cookie Recipes

Setting up an ice cream sundae bar is an activity that is as fun to prepare as it is to enjoy. Whether it’s for a special occasion or just a way to make a weekend extra sweet, the versatility and interactive nature of a sundae bar make it a winner every time. 

If you’re hosting a party, celebration, or even just a night in with friends, I hope you’ll give this ice cream sundae bar idea a try!  If you do, please leave a comment and a 5-star rating below. 

Want more from Inspired by Charm? Join the IBC Mailing List for inspiration in your inbox! Follow along on Instagram and TikTok for daily updates and behind-the-scenes looks at my processes. There’s even more inspiration on Facebook and Pinterest!